Suite à un entretien avec Dylan pour le Melody Maker en 78, Robert Shelton parle de la dimension très personnelle du morceau, de ce qu'elle nous dit sur la relation de Dylan avec son public et son art.
"A close listening to many of the lyrics of "Street-Legal" reveals
a set of narrators who are oppressed, lonely, wandering and
alienated - in a foreign country.
"Where Are You Tonight?" may very well be his most direct
confessional of pain and loss. Yet at Blackbushe, he'd changed the
new song, brightened its tempo, muted the oppresive tone.
The pained lyrics hid behind the music of dark glasses, yet they
were still there. That time, the song seemed less to express
anguish than to convey that anguish had been exercised.
Recently, Dylan's been showing rare candour in stepping out from
behind another persona by introducing "Shelter From The Storm" as
"the story of my life".
The song tells of the flight of a man, who is living in a foreign
country, from toil, blood and doom. In his moment of greatest
need, the narrator finds that safe, warm shelter with a woman. Then,
he loses her. I find the desperation of that search still strong
in "Street-Legal".
I pressed Dylan to tell me more about one of his most intriguing
formulations: "No man can fight another like the man who fights
himself. Who could be a stronger enemy?"
"It's true that a man is his own worst enemy, just as he is his
own best friend. If you deal with the enemy within, then no enemy
without can stand a chance", Dylan says.
I probed dangerous territory. What is "the enemy without"? Dylan
replied tersely: "Suspicion". Could he put his finger on "the
enemy within"?
He laughed at my question. "I'll draw you a picture for the cover
of your book", he said, "with a big finger pointing to the enemy
within!" He poked his index-finger toward his heart.
"Come on, man", I pleaded. Cautiously, Bob said: "It's all in
those two verses of that last song,", directing me to "Where Are
You Tonight?".
The lines begin: "I fought with my twin, that enemy within/'til
both of us fell by whe way..." (Copyright © 1978, Big Ben Music,
Ltd.) The clue haunts me. Is "the enemy within" Dylan's Gemini
twins locked in mortal combat? Is it the id battling the ego? Is
it the death-trip threatening the life-force?
In an earlier song, there was an encounter with a different kind
of "twin". In "Simple Twist Of Fate" Dylan sang: "People tell me
it's a sin/To know and feel too much within". (Copyright © 1978,
Big Ben Music, Ltd.)
That's how we can all have our dialogue with Dylan, and he with
us. During most interviews, he has used wit and cunning to conceal
his personal emotions. Then he'll turn around and tell the whole
world about his feelings in his lyrics, if you can penetrate the
ambiguities and the codes and the shifting personas."
_________________